In Outstanding Compensation… High Court Orders Jinshi Mining to Pay Mokombay Farmers NLe 570,000

The High Court of Sierra Leone has ordered Jinshi Mining (SL) Limited to pay NLe 570,000 in outstanding crop compensation to farmers in Mokombay Village, Lower Banta Chiefdom, Moyamba District, in a significant ruling that reinforces the protection of customary land and crop ownership rights under the Customary Land Rights Act, 2022.

The judgment, delivered by Honourable Justice Abdul Rahman Mansaray, underscores the legal responsibility of mining companies and other investors to compensate individuals whose crops are destroyed or affected by their investment activities.

Delivering his judgment, Honourable Justice Abdul Rahman Mansaray emphasized that Section 39 of the Customary Land Rights Act, 2022, imposes a mandatory obligation on investors to pay compensation directly to crop owners for losses resulting from their operations. He clarified that payments made to Paramount Chiefs or other third parties cannot constitute valid compensation unless the affected crop owners have legally authorized those individuals to receive the money on their behalf.

The ruling followed legal action supported by Namati Sierra Leone on behalf of farmers whose agricultural lands and crops were affected by the expansion of Jinshi Mining (SL) Limited’s rutile mining operations in Mokombay Village.

Jinshi Mining (SL) Limited, a Chinese-owned mining company that commenced operations in Moyamba District in 2022, expanded its activities into agricultural lands belonging to six villages in Lower Banta Chiefdom in 2024. The expansion reportedly resulted in the destruction of crops that served as the primary source of income and livelihood for several farming households.

Although compensation arrangements had been agreed upon, affected farmers in Mokombay Village maintained that they had not received the payments owed to them for their destroyed crops.

While acknowledging its responsibility to compensate the affected farmers, Jinshi Mining (SL) Limited argued that it had fulfilled its obligation by making payments through the Paramount Chief, citing what it described as established customary practices within the chiefdom.

The Court, however, rejected the company’s argument, maintaining that customary practices cannot override statutory provisions enacted by Parliament, particularly when such practices conflict with rights expressly protected under national legislation.

Honourable Justice Abdul Rahman Mansaray explained that Section 39 of the Customary Land Rights Act, 2022, specifically identifies crop owners as the rightful beneficiaries of compensation and does not authorize investors to make payments to Paramount Chiefs, chiefdom authorities or other intermediaries without the consent of the affected individuals.

“Whenever Parliament legislates upon a subject, any inconsistent customary practice becomes subordinate to the statute,” Honourable Justice Abdul Rahman Mansaray stated.

The Court further warned that allowing investors to fulfil their compensation obligations through payments to third parties could expose vulnerable farmers to the risk of misappropriation, unnecessary delays or the complete failure to receive compensation.

For the affected farming families, the prolonged compensation dispute reportedly had serious economic and social consequences, affecting their ability to sustain their households and finance their children’s education.

One of the affected farmers, Victor Musa, explained that the failure to receive the outstanding compensation had placed considerable financial pressure on his family, particularly in meeting educational expenses.

“Our children’s education has been at a standstill for months because we were relying on that money to pay school fees. Since we haven’t received it, we’ve been unable to pay, and some of our children have been forced to drop out,” Victor Musa said.

Faced with those challenges, the farmers sought legal intervention with support from Namati Sierra Leone, which assisted them in pursuing their compensation claims and seeking clarification of investors’ legal obligations under the Customary Land Rights Act, 2022.

Another affected landowner, Morie Marju, welcomed the judgment, describing the legal battle as a difficult experience that required considerable patience, determination and confidence in the judicial process.

“We are very happy with the judgement. It was a real struggle. We were told that we were wasting our time trusting in the process, but Namati came through for us. We are happy,” Morie Marju stated.

The judgment represents an important affirmation of the legal protections provided under the Customary Land Rights Act, 2022, particularly for rural communities whose agricultural lands and livelihoods are increasingly affected by mining, agribusiness and other large-scale investment activities.

Beyond the immediate order for the payment of NLe 570,000, the ruling serves as an important legal reminder that investors cannot rely solely on traditional administrative arrangements to fulfil statutory obligations owed directly to crop owners.

It also reinforces the principle that customary land governance must operate within the framework of national legislation, particularly where the rights, livelihoods and economic interests of vulnerable communities are concerned.

For mining companies and other investors operating in Sierra Leone, the decision highlights the importance of establishing transparent compensation arrangements, engaging directly with affected landowners and crop owners and ensuring strict compliance with the legal safeguards provided under the Customary Land Rights Act, 2022.

The support provided by Namati Sierra Leone throughout the legal proceedings also demonstrates the importance of legal empowerment in helping rural communities understand, assert  and defend their rights when confronted with powerful commercial interests.

With Sierra Leone continuing to attract investment in its mining and agricultural sectors, the Mokombay judgment serves as a significant reminder that economic development and commercial expansion must not come at the expense of the rights, livelihoods and dignity of communities whose lands and natural resources sustain those investments.

The Calabash Newspaper
The Calabash Newspaperhttps://thecalabashnewspaper.com
The Calabash Newspaper is Sierra Leone's leading English-language news platform, established in 2017 to provide trusted news, investigative journalism, politics, business, health, sports, and current affairs to audiences in Sierra Leone and around the world.

Related Articles

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Stay Connected

- Advertisement - spot_img

Latest Articles

- Advertisement - spot_img